Evaluasi Perbandingan Laravel Blade dan Livewire pada Sistem Presensi Akademik

Ali Sadikin; Abdul Rahim; Muhammad Wardani; Irawan Irawan

doi:10.61132/prosemnasproit.v2i2.79

Authors

Ali Sadikin Universitas Dinamika Bangsa
Abdul Rahim Universitas Dinamika Bangsa
Muhammad Wardani Universitas Dinamika Bangsa
Irawan Irawan Universitas Dinamika Bangsa

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.61132/prosemnasproit.v2i2.79

Keywords:

Laravel Livewire, Load Testing, Performa Web, K6

Abstract

The increasing demand for interactive web applications has encouraged the adoption of server-driven approaches such as Livewire as an alternative to building Single Page Applications (SPAs) without complex client-side JavaScript. However, the performance implications of this approach compared to conventional methods remain insufficiently explored. This study presents an empirical comparison between Laravel Blade with AJAX and Livewire in an academic attendance system scenario. Performance evaluation was conducted using k6 on the same web server, complemented by manual browser-based testing to observe actual communication patterns. The results indicate that Livewire exhibits approximately 2.7× higher average response time and up to 6× greater bandwidth consumption than Laravel Blade, primarily due to its snapshot mechanism and state synchronization process. Conversely, Livewire demonstrates better stability, reflected by lower maximum response times and a 0% error rate. These findings highlight a clear trade-off between resource efficiency and development convenience, where Livewire favors stability and developer productivity, while Laravel Blade provides superior efficiency in terms of latency and bandwidth usage.

References

Amarulloh, A., K. Kurniasih, and M. Muchlis. 2023. “Analisis Perbandingan Performa Web Service REST Menggunakan Framework Laravel, Django, Dan Node JS Pada Aplikasi Berbasis Website.” Jurnal Teknik Informatika 9(1):12–17.

Ambara, M. P., M. Sudiarta, S. M. Suryaniadi, and I. G. T. S. Dharma. 2025. “Implementation of the CodeIgniter Framework in the Development of a Cloud-Based Competency Assessment System.” Pp. 421–30 in International Conference on Sustainable Green Tourism Applied Science-Engineering Applied Science 2025 (ICOSTAS-EAS 2025). Atlantis Press.

Hadinata, M. S., and R. W. Stianingsih. 2024. “Analisis Perbandingan Performa RESTful API Antara Express.Js Dengan Laravel Framework.” Jurnal Informatika Dan Teknik Elektro Terapan (JITET) 7(2):545–54. doi:10.35313/jitet.v7i2.3845.

Hendayun, M., A. Ginanjar, and Y. Ihsan. 2023. “Analysis of Application Performance Testing Using Load Testing and Stress Testing Methods in API Service.” Jurnal Sisfotek Global 13(1):28. doi:10.38101/sisfotek.v13i1.2656.

Hikmat, A. N. 2024. “Evaluasi Desain Interface Pada Aplikasi Ipusnas Berdasarkan Teori Evaluasi Heuristik Nielsen.” LIBRIA 16(1):16–36.

JetBrains. 2023. “Developer Ecosystem Survey 2023.”

Kansha, W. M. 2023. “Analisis Perbandingan Struktur Dan Performa Framework CodeIgniter Dan Laravel Dalam Pengembangan Web Application.” Jurnal Teknik Informatika STMIK Antar Bangsa 9(1):25–30.

Labs, Grafana. 2024. “K6 Load Testing Documentation.”

Liu, W., L. Guo, Y. W. Heng, C. Li, A. E. Hassan, and others. 2025. “Screencast-Based Analysis of User-Perceived GUI Responsiveness.” ArXiv Preprint ArXiv:2508.01337.

Otwell, Taylor. 2024. “Laravel Documentation.”

Porzio, Caleb. 2024. “Laravel Livewire Documentation.”

Pradana, F. A. 2024. “Perancangan Sistem Presensi Deteksi Wajah Berbasis Website (Studi Kasus Laboratorium Sistem Manufaktur Terintegrasi UII).” Universitas Islam Indonesia.

Pratama, F., and A. Farisi. 2025. “Analisis Perbandingan Kinerja Backend API Menggunakan PHP, Golang, Dan JavaScript.” Techno Com 24(1).

Purwanto, B., H. Nugroho, and A. Wijayanto. 2018. “Pengembangan Dashboard Akademik Berbasis Data Warehouse Di Perguruan Tinggi.” Jurnal Teknologi Informasi Dan Komputer 4(1):12–20.

Stauffer, Matt. 2023. “Understanding Livewire: Server-Side Framework for Laravel.”

Teslenko, Y. 2025. “Performance Percentile Analysis for API-Based Testing.” Авторський Колектив 235.